Salvatore's Tomato Pies Menu

Welcome to Salvatore's Tomato Pies, a cherished spot located at 121 E Main St, Sun Prairie, WI. This restaurant is where traditional Italian flavors meet contemporary dining. Renowned for its phenomenal pizzas, Salvatore's has won over many locals, including those from Madison, with its consistently top-quality dishes.

  • Signature Dishes: The menu features delectable offerings such as Sal's Meatballs, smothered in a savory house red sauce, and a variety of pizzas that leave diners raving.
  • Appetizers: Don’t miss the garlic bread paired with house marinara, or the indulgent truffle fries, which have become a favorite among patrons.
  • Kids Menu: Tailored for younger diners, the kids' buttered noodles and mac & cheese ensure there's something for everyone.
  • Unique Cocktails: Their cocktail menu stands out with creative options like the Better Than Beer Paloma.

With warm service and a lively atmosphere, Salvatore’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a community hub where flavorful dishes and friendly faces converge.

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - 10' & Gf Pies*

10' Sal's Supreme

Red sauce, Italian sausage, green bell pepper, Crimini mushrooms, onion, black olives. *Make it a Vegan!

$19.50

10' Fat Uncle Tony

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce, Fresh Basil

$19.50

10' Joey Bananas

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Fresh Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Hot Honey, Fresh Basil

$19.50

10' Walter White

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, spinach, garlic, ricotta and chili flakes

$19.50

10' Woodsman

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives

$19.50

10' Tomato Pie

The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910

$14.70

10' Figgy Piggy

Wine poached figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, pepitas, hot honey

$19.50

10' The Gem

Fresh mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Meatballs, Fresno Pepper, Basil. Want it less spicy, order without the Fresno Peppers.

$19.50

16' Fat Uncle Tony

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Pepperoni, Red Sauce, Fresh Basil

$31.50

16' Figgy Piggy

Wine Poached Figs, prosciutto, gorgonzola, arugula, pepitas, hot honey drizzle

$31.50

16' Joey Bananas

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Sartori MontAmore, House Red Sauce, Tempesta Uncured Pepperoni, Fresh Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Hot Honey, Fresh Basil

$31.50

16' Sal's Supreme

Red sauce, Italian sausage, green bell pepper, mushroom, onion, black olive *Make it a Vegan Supreme!

$32.40

16' The Gem

Fresh mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, Meatballs, Fresno Pepper, Basil. Want it less spicy, order without the Fresno Peppers.

$31.50

16' The Tomato Pie

The Classic but built in reverse; Crust, Olive Oil, Romano, Wisconsin Whole Milk Mozzarella, and House Red Sauce, finished with Fresh Basil. Think Margherita. This style of pizza was created in Trenton, NJ, back in 1910. TO add additional toppings please navigate to the Build Your Own Pie

$21.42

16' Walter White

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Italian Sausage, spinach, garlic, ricotta and chili flakes

$31.50

16' Woodsman

Whole Milk Mozzarella, Brown Butter Sauteed Leek, Cremini, Oyster and Shiitake Mushrooms, Pleasant Ridge Reserve, Truffle Oil, Black Pepper, Fresh Chives

$31.50

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - 16' Pies*

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Build Your Own Pies*

10' Build Your Own Pie

All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.

$14.70

16' Build Your Own Pie

All pies start with olive oil, Romano, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella and red sauce. Add your own toppings to create the perfect pie.

$21.42

Caesar Salad

Romaine, Shaved SarVecchio, Parmesan Crisps, House Caesar Dressing and Fresh Dill

$15.60

Classic Setup Burger

1/3 lb Wells Farm Beef, Stalzy's Butter Bun, American Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle, Onion

$15.60

Market Salad

Mixed Greens with Market Vegetables, SarVecchio, and House Seasonal Vinaigrette

$14.40

Sal's Meatballs

Italian-style meatballs in House Red Sauce with SarVecchio & finished with Fresh Parsley. Served with Grilled Bread

$14.40

The BOF Burger

Well's Farm beef, Ann in a Jam brandy Old Fashioned cherry jam, caramelized apple, bacon, brown butter, red onion, arugula, Stalzy's butter bun

$18.60

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Lunch Menu*

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Appetizers*

French Fries

Lightly seasoned

$9.00

Sal's Meatballs

Italian-style meatballs in House Red Sauce with SarVecchio & finished with Fresh Parsley. Served with Grilled Bread

$14.40

Garlic Bread

Toasted baguette, garlic butter, sarvecchio parmesan, and confit garlic. served with house marinara.

$9.00

Classic Setup Burger

1/3 lb, Wells Farm Beef, Stalzy's Butter Bun, American Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle & Onion.

$15.60

The BOF Burger

Well's Farm beef, Ann in a Jam brandy Old Fashioned cherry jam, caramelized apple, bacon, brown butter, red onion, arugula, Stalzy's butter bun

$18.60

Worlds Best Meatball Sub

Grandma Aversano’s famous meatballs, house red sauce, pesto, provolone, Romano and parsley on a Philly hoagie roll. It’s a meal!

$13.40

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Burgers And Sandwiches

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Pasta & Entrees*

Bucatini

House Bucatini, Sartori SarVecchio, House Red Sauce, Parsley, Bread

$28.80

Rigatoni Bolognese

House Rigatoni, Wells Farm Beef and Pork Ragu, Whipped Ricotta, Fresh Parsely

$29.40

Chicken Brown Butter Pasta

House made gnocchi sardi, grilled chicken, asparagus, cremini mushroom, brown butter cream, Romano, chives and chili crisps

$22.80

Market Salad

Mixed Greens with Market Vegetables, SarVecchio, and House Seasonal Vinaigrette

$14.20

Caesar Salad

Romaine, Shaved SarVecchio, Parmesan Crisps, House Caesar Dressing and Fresh Dill

$15.60

Italian American Wedge Salad

Creamy herb dressing, iceberg lettuce, basil, tomatoes, banana peppers, red onion, gorgonzola, pepperoni, olive oil and vinegar. (serves 2)

$15.00

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Salads*

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Dessert*

Chocolate Cake

House-made Chocolate Cake with Dark Chocolate Ganache, served with Seasonal Fruit Compote

$8.40

Butterscotch Budino

Budino, Caramel, Smoked Salt, served with a Shortbread Cookie

$10.80

Cannoli

Old Family Recipe with seasonal Fruit compote

$9.60

Kids Mac & Cheese

Macaroni, House Cheese Sauce, served with Seasonal Viniagrette

$8.40

Kids Buttered Noodles

Buttered Macaroni served with Seasonal Vegetable

$7.20

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Kids Menu*

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - N/A Cocktails*

Better Than Beer Gin And Tonic

Gin and tonic reimagined with a unique twist, offering a refreshing alternative to traditional beer options.

$7.00

Better Than Beer Paloma

A twist on the classic, blending tequila with grapefruit juice, a hint of lime, and soda, garnished to enhance the experience.

$7.00

Mexican Coca-Cola

The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.

$4.80

Potosi Golden Brew NA

Potosi Golden Brew NA is a non-alcoholic beverage, offering a refreshing and crisp taste, often crafted to mimic traditional beer flavors without the alcohol content.

$7.00

Riverwest Stein NA

Riverwest Stein NA, a non-alcoholic soda, offers a refreshing and crisp beverage experience, typically featuring a unique blend of flavors.

$7.00

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - To Go Drinks*

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Cans & Bottles

Barq's Root Beer 12oz

A sweet, spiced favorite that’s stood the test of time.

$2.50

Coke 12oz

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$2.50

Diet Coke 12oz

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

$2.50

Barritt's Ginger Beer

A non-alcoholic beverage, infused with the bold taste of ginger, offering a spicy and refreshing experience.

$4.80

Grapefruit Jarritos

A Mexican soda infused with natural grapefruit flavor, sweetened with real sugar.

$4.80

Mexican Coke

The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.

$5.00

San Pellegrino 16oz

Effervescent Pellegrino Sparkling Water, Refreshing with a Crisp Finish

$5.00

Pellegrino Limonata

Pellegrino Limonata is a sparkling lemon beverage, featuring a blend of ripe lemon juice that offers a refreshing and zesty taste.

$3.00

Sprecher Root Beer

A rich, handcrafted root beer with a smooth, creamy flavor and hints of vanilla and wintergreen.

$4.00

Sprite 12oz

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

$2.50

Mello Yello 12oz

The smooth citrus soda taste that has refreshed people's thirst for over two decades.

$2.50

Sprecher Cream Soda

A classic, creamy soda with a smooth vanilla flavor, typically enjoyed for its rich and nostalgic taste.

$6.00

Sprecher Orange Dream

Handcrafted Italian soda with orange flavor, typically includes a hint of cream for a smooth, dreamy finish.

$6.00

Sprecher Grape

A refreshing grape juice with a rich and sweet grape flavor, typically enjoyed for its natural fruitiness and smooth finish.

$6.00

Diet Coke 2L

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

$5.50

Mello Yello 2L

A 2-liter bottle of Mello Yello, a citrus-flavored carbonated soft drink.

$5.50

Minute Made Lemonade 2L

A two-liter bottle of freshly squeezed orange juice, typically including a natural and refreshing citrus flavor.

$5.50

Sprite 1L

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

$3.00

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - 2 Liters

Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Specials

Italian American Wedge Salad

Iceberg lettuce wedge topped with crispy pancetta, red onion, grape tomatoes, pepperoncini, and crumbled gorgonzola, drizzled with a creamy blue cheese dressing.

$15.00

Friday Fish Fry

Beer battered Alaskan Pacific Cod served with Fries, House-made Coleslaw and Tartar Sauce. Only available on Friday!

$19.00