Welcome to Salvatore's Tomato Pies
Salvatore's Tomato Pies, located in Sun Prairie, WI, is a culinary gem known for its exceptional pizza offerings and vibrant atmosphere. Founded with a passion for authentic Italian flavors, this restaurant specializes in both traditional and innovative pies, such as the flavorful Figgy Piggy and the savory Woodsman. Beyond pizza, the menu dazzles with Italian-style meatballs, gourmet burgers, and children’s options, ensuring there's something for everyone. Patrons rave about the attentive service, delightful happy hour specials, and unique features like robotic pizza delivery. Salvatore's epitomizes the charm of community dining, making it a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike.
Salvatore's Tomato Pies: Reviews & Ratings
We love coming to Salvators! The best part (aside from The food ) is the happy hour prices. 5 off 10" pies if you sit at the bar. Also, happy hour prices on draft beervand mixers. We are always extremely happy with our experience.
Best pizza in Madison by a mile. Absolutely phenomenal service and always top quality food!
Love Sal's, best pizza in Sun Prairie! The burgers are always excellent too. (My husband will get a burger every time we eat in). Don't sleep on the specials—they're incredible! We've been getting the pint of pasta fagiole soup to go with our delivery because it makes such a good lunch for the next few days.
Wow this place has some great pizza and the service is great!
Visited Salvatore's for dinner with my daughter. Very cool restaurant and atmosphere. Service was great - attentive and polite. We had the truffle fries and a large Fat Uncle Tony pizza. The fries were amazing...my daughter said they are her new favorite and would stop again for the fries alone. The pizza was equally fantastic. We ended up bringing half the pizza back home with us. However, the coolest thing might have been the robot that delivered pizzas and salads from the back of the restaurant to the front for carryout. It was so cool. It also looks like their carryout business was quite busy...which I would consider carryout in the future, but the atmosphere inside is certainly worth going inside to sit down. Great place. Will visit again and again!
The Sweet Side of Winter" pie Kale, Springdale Farm sweet potato puree, goat cheese, bacon, pickled red onion, Harmony Valley sunchoke chips, Vitruvian Farm pea shoots. This was the pizza I tried today and it was absolutely delicious as always. I haven't gotten one there ever changing monthly pies I didn't like. As well there regular pies on the menu are just as delicious. Definitely stop by check em out.
The wait was about 30 minutes to get your food. The food was really great. Highly suggest their Main Event Burger, there is no need to add anything to their burger, it is great as is. Their truffle fries were good as well but I wish it was included in the meal and not an extra 4. You end up with a burger and fries for almost 19. Their old fashioned was good with the brandy.
So last time I ordered I got the cheese pizza and it was really good, so I tried to order it again, but I accidentally got the world class tomato pizza, and it was really really good. It is like cheese pizza but with a hint of the sweet tomato. It was really really good. I would definitely suggest it. So I got all of this delicious food for delivery, and my deliver driver was Teddy he was very speedy and friendly. It is important to remember to tip the delivery driver because they work very hard. Also if you don’t end up eating all of your pizza in one day, it tastes just as good if you reheat it, so that’s a plus!! 10/10
Location
-
121 E Main St, Sun Prairie, WI 53590, United States Hotline: +1 608-318-1761
Welcome to Salvatore's Tomato Pies, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. Located at 121 E Main St, this restaurant has become a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike. Known for its exceptional pizzas, hearty burgers, and a vibrant atmosphere, Salvatore's promises a delightful dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
One standout aspect of Salvatore's is their signature Build Your Own Pizza. Starting with a foundation of olive oil, Romano cheese, Wisconsin whole milk mozzarella, and robust red sauce, diners have the freedom to craft the perfect pie tailored to their tastes. Whether you opt for classic toppings or venture into more adventurous territories, the choices are plentiful and satisfying.
- Classic Setup Burger: Indulge in a perfectly grilled 1/3 lb Wells Farm beef patty, nestled in a Stalzy's butter bun with American cheddar, fresh lettuce, and tomatoes. Priced at $15.60, this burger is an excellent representation of comfort food.
- BOF Burger: Elevating the burger game, this option features Wells Farm beef with Ann in a Jam brandy Old Fashioned cherry jam, caramelized apple, bacon, and red onion. At $18.60, it’s a burst of sweet and savory flavors that you won’t want to miss.
- World's Best Meatball Sub: Made with Grandma Aversano’s famous meatballs, house red sauce, pesto, provolone, and Romano, this delicious sandwich is a crowd favorite that encapsulates warmth and nostalgia.
Reviews from satisfied patrons echo the restaurant's reputation. One customer, Erica Andrus, praised the stellar happy hour offerings, while Ben Delaney exclaims it’s “the best pizza in Madison by a mile.” Elizabeth Shimek values the diverse menu, frequently choosing a burger and a pint of pasta fagiole soup for a satisfying meal. The restaurant’s service is consistently noted as attentive and polite, enhancing the overall dining experience.
In addition to the outstanding food, diners can enjoy a unique touch with technology, as a robot assists in delivering pizzas and salads from the kitchen to the front, bringing a playful yet modern element to your visit.
All in all, Salvatore's Tomato Pies stands out with its high-quality ingredients, welcoming atmosphere, and inventive menu. Whether you're here for a casual meal or a special night out, this restaurant leaves a lasting impression that resonates well beyond the final bite. Your tastebuds are sure to thank you!